Home

Flat Owner Cannot Be Deprived Of Basic Amenities Due To Builder Disputes: Calcutta HC

Copy LinkShareSave

Isolating flat owners and denying them basic gated-community utilities over pending disputes with real estate developers constitutes an impermissible exercise of arbitrary authority by housing associations. Restoring essential digital access to an aggrieved homebuyer, the High Court held that ongoing proceedings between developers and management bodies cannot be weaponized to strip individual residents of fundamental residential amenities.

A Division Bench comprising Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya and Justice Sandip Kumar De addressed an appeal challenging a trial court order that had refused interim relief to a unit owner seeking restoration of residential app-based access and gas supply services.

Key Takeaways

Protection from Collateral Hostility: Individual apartment purchasers cannot be targeted or deprived of basic living amenities due to ongoing disputes between residential associations and property developers.

Scope of Interim Relief: Arbitration clauses existing strictly between a purchaser and a developer cannot be invoked by a third-party residential association to bar civil court relief against the association.

Maintenance of Essential Access: Granting interim access to essential technological applications governing entry and exit is vital to safeguard basic rights of user and title.

Court Observations and Directions

The High Court observed that while multiple proceedings were pending across various forums involving the developer, association, and residents, individual unit owners could not be singled out or penalized. The Court highlighted that the flat purchaser had acquired the unit for valuable consideration and that alleged unauthorized constructions inside the unit stood regularized by the municipal authority under Section 400(1) and Section 415 of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation Act, 1980.

The Court, in its reasoning, observed: "It further appears that the plaintiff/appellant is being singled out and being deprived of the basic amenities required at the said unit inside the complex. The association may have complaints or allegations against the developer but for said reason, the plaintiff/appellant cannot be made to suffer."

Regarding interim directions, the Court modified the trial court's order. The Court has following directions:

"However, since the appellant has made out a strong prima facie case of title and right of user to the suit flat and entry and exit to the same, the respondents are directed to allow the appellant to continue using the ‘My Gate App’ meant for entry and exit to the complex. The impugned order dated July 17th, 2025 passed by the learned Civil Judge, (Senior Division), 4th Court at Alipore, the Title Suit no.1060 of 2025 is modified to such extent."

While declining to pass immediate orders on the gas line installation to avoid prejudging the pending interim injunction application before the trial court, the High Court directed the trial court to dispose of the injunction application expeditiously within one month without granting unnecessary adjournments.

Ratio

Residential housing associations cannot restrict or deny essential user rights, basic amenities, or entry-exit access to valid property titleholders on account of independent legal controversies or structural disputes existing with the property developer.

Background

The dispute originated when an individual purchased a residential unit in a housing complex on February 9, 2024. Following complaints lodged by the owners' association regarding alleged unapproved constructions, proceedings were initiated under Section 400(1) read with Section 415 of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation Act, 1980. The municipal authorities subsequently regularized the constructions upon payment of required retention fees.

Despite the regularization, the association denied membership to the purchaser and blocked access to 'My Gate App' the mandatory digital platform controlling complex entry and exit as well as connection to the centralized gas bank. The purchaser filed a civil suit seeking declarations of title and sub-lease rights, alongside access to essential common services defining 'common areas' under Section 2(n)(v) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016.

The trial court initially refused ad-interim injunction on the ground that the sub-lease deed contained an arbitration clause under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Challenging this refusal, the appellant cited Hammad Ahmed Vs. Abdul Majid and Ors. ( "(2019) 14 SCC 1": 2019 CaseBase(SC) 2609) to contend that mandatory interim protection and status quo ante can be granted when a strong prima facie case is established.

The High Court held that the arbitration clause in the sub-lease agreement between developer and purchaser did not impede civil remedies against the association, modifying the trial court's order to grant immediate digital entry access while expediting the trial court's hearing on utility connections.

Case Details:
Case No.: FMA 763 OF 2026 WITH CAN 1 OF 2025
Neutral Citation: 2026:CHC-AS:1284-DB
Case Title: Ambica Beri VS Forum Atmosphere Flat Owners Association and Ors.
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. Rudraman Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv., Mr. Shuvasish Sengupta, Adv., Mr. Sourojit Dasgupta, Adv., Mr. Sushovit Dutt Majumder, Adv., Mr. Souvik Ganguly, Adv., Ms. Rajeshwari Prasad, Adv.
For the Respondent(s): Mr. Joydeep Kar, Snr. Adv., Mr. Krishna Raj Thakker, Snr. Adv., Mr. Aniruddha Chatterjee, Sr. Adv., Mr. Shoham Sanyal, Adv. (for Respondent No. 1); Mr. Debangshu Ghatak, Adv., Mr. Upasana Bhattasali, Adv. (for Respondent No. 2)

Source: 2026 CaseBase(CAL) 1644

 /