Home

SDM Cannot Curtail Duration of Fair Contrary to Tender Conditions: Madhya Pradesh HC

Copy LinkShareSave

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has directed the Municipal Council to ensure that a successful bidder is allowed to conduct a religious fair for the full 45-day duration as originally stipulated in the tender, holding that administrative authorities cannot unilaterally curtail contractual periods.

In a recent ruling, Justice Milind Ramesh Phadke addressed a petition challenging the arbitrary reduction of the 'Shree Siddheshwar Banganga Mela 2026' duration from 45 days to a mere 22 days. The Court emphasized that once a party has altered its position by depositing substantial sums based on tender conditions, the essential terms of the contract must be upheld.

SDM Lacks Jurisdiction to Regulate Fairs under Municipal Law

The petitioner, a proprietorship firm, had emerged as the successful bidder for organizing the mela with a bid of over Rs. 51 lakhs. Despite the tender specifying a 45-day period, the Sub-Divisional Officer (SDM) of Shivpuri issued a communication restricting the event to 22 days. The petitioner argued that under Section 124(bb) of the Madhya Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1961, the power to regulate and grant permission for fairs rests exclusively with the Municipal Council and not the SDM.

Court Protects Contractual Rights of Successful Bidders

The Court observed that the petitioner had already incurred significant expenses for the establishment and operation of the fair. It noted that the State authorities could not alter the essential terms of the tender to the prejudice of the petitioner after the bid was accepted and consideration paid.

The Court, in its reasoning, observed: "If the Municipal Council intended to organize the Mela for the said period and accepted consideration from the petitioner on that basis, then it is the responsibility of the Municipal Council to ensure availability of the land and necessary arrangements for the entire contractual period."

The Court has the following directions:

"i. The Municipal Council/concerned respondent authorities to take immediate steps to obtain and secure the requisite land from the competent State authorities, if such land is not presently available with the Municipal Council, and thereafter hand over the same to the petitioner for conducting and operating Shree Siddheshwar Banganga Mela, 2026.

ii. The respondent authorities shall ensure that the petitioner is permitted to conduct and operate the Mela for a total period of 45 days, being the period contemplated under the tender conditions and on the basis whereof the petitioner was declared a successful bidder.

iii. In the event the original site is not available or it is not feasible to continue the Mela at the same location, the respondent authorities shall identify and provide a suitable alternative site and permit the petitioner to shift and continue the Mela therefrom.

iv. The petitioner shall be entitled to continue and run the Mela for a cumulative period of 45 days, and the respondents shall extend all necessary cooperation for the said purpose."

Background:

The dispute arose when the petitioner, having won the tender for Rs. 51,11,501/-, was served with a permission letter by respondent No. 4, based on the SDM’s communication, which limited the fair's operation from June 4 to June 25, 2026. This was contrary to the 45-day period promised during the bidding process. The petitioner approached the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking to set aside the restrictive order and for a direction to extend the mela's duration to recover the lost period. The Court disposed of the petition by granting the relief sought, ensuring the petitioner receives the full 45-day operational window.

Case Details:
Case No.: WRIT PETITION No. 21576 of 2026
NeutralCitation: 2026:MPHC-GWL:18406
Case Title: KRISHNA ENTERPREISES THROUGH ITS PROPRIETOR BHAGCHAND SHIVHARE Versus THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): Shri Pallav Tripathi - Advocate
For the Respondent(s): Shri Dharmendra Nayak GA for Advocate General, Shri Kunal Suryavanshi - Advocate for respondent [R-4]

Source: 2026 CaseBase(MP) 66