Home

Bombay HC Permits Underground Power Cables on Public Road Despite Private Ownership Claims

Copy LinkShareSave

In a significant ruling, the Bombay High Court has set aside lower court orders that stalled the laying of vital electricity infrastructure, emphasizing the public interest in unobstructed access for power transmission. The Court held that when an underground cable is being laid through a method that causes minimal damage, the balance of convenience tilts in favor of infrastructure development rather than private property claims that lack prima facie evidence.

Justice N. J. Jamadar presided over the matter, hearing a writ petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, 1950. The petition challenged concurrent findings of a Trial Court and District Court which had refused to grant a temporary injunction against several individuals who were obstructing the final 200-meter stretch of a 14-km long high-tension cable project.

Judicial Rationale: Public Interest in Infrastructure

The Court observed that the Petitioner had obtained all necessary permissions from authorities like MSEDCL, MIDC, and the Zilla Parishad. While the lower courts were swayed by the Defendants' claims that the road was their private land, the High Court found that the existence of a public road on the disputed stretch was prima facie established by a Court Commissioner's report.

The Court, in its reasoning, observed: "As per the provisions of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885, unobstructed access to lay down telegraph and/or electricity transmission lines is an imperative in the larger public interest. Electrification of villages all over the country and availability of telegraph lines are the most essential requirements for growth and development of any country, economy and the well-being/progress of the citizens. The legislature has not permitted any kind of impediment/ obstruction in achieving this objective and through the scheme of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 empowering the licensee to lay telegraph lines, applied the same, as it is, for laying down the electricity transmission lines."

Application of Legal Precedents

The Court relied on Power Grid Corporation of India Limited Vs Century Textiles And Industries Limited and Ors ( "(2017) 5 SCC 143": 2016 CaseBase(SC) 1129) and Century Rayon Limited Vs IVP Limited And Ors ( "(2021) 20 SCC 758": 2019 CaseBase(SC) 1987) to underscore that even where cables are laid through private property, the owner’s primary right is to claim compensation under the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885, rather than halting the work. It further noted that the Plaintiff’s use of horizontal directional drilling (HDD) technology ensures that agricultural use of the surface land remains unaffected. Integrating the principles from Hubbard And Anr Vs Vosper And Anr, the Court noted that while interim relief usually shouldn't amount to final relief, exceptional circumstances involving irreparable loss to infrastructure projects justify such a move.

The Court has following directions:

"(i) The Petition stands allowed. (ii) The impugned order dated 30th August 2025 as well as the order dated 12th July 2024 passed by the learned Civil Judge, rejecting the Application for temporary injunction stands quashed and set aside. (iii) The application for temporary injunction (Exhibit “5”) stands allowed in terms of prayer clause (a) subject to the following conditions: (a) The work of laying underground cable shall be carried out in scrupulous compliance with the conditions subject to which the permissions have been granted by the concerned Authorities and by following the HDD (horizontal directional drilling) boring method, causing minimum possible damage to the land beneath which the cable is proposed to be laid. (b) The Plaintiff shall deposit a sum of Rs.20,00,000/- before the trial Court by way of security for the compensation which the trial Court may award to the Defendants in the event the Plaintiff fails. (c) The trial Court shall invest the said amount of Rs.20,00,000/- in an interest bearing account and the said amount shall abide the final outcome of the suit."

Background:

The Petitioner, a confectionery manufacturer, required additional power supply and received sanction to lay a 14-km express feeder line. While 13.8 km was completed, the Respondents obstructed the final 200 meters, claiming the land beneath the public road was their private property. The Trial Court and District Court had initially sided with the Respondents, citing the availability of an alternative remedy under Rule 3 of the Works Of Licensees Rules, 2006 and the Specific Relief Act, 1963. However, the High Court noted that the Works Of Licensees Rules, 2006 was not strictly applicable as the Respondents failed to prima facie prove ownership of the road stretch. The Court eventually allowed the petition, permitting the completion of the work subject to a security deposit to protect the Respondents' potential compensation rights.

Case Details: Case No.: WRIT PETITION NO. 12747 OF 2025 Case Title: Mondelez India Foods Private Limited Vs. Vishal Pansare and Ors. Appearances: For the Petitioner(s): Mr. Zal Andhyarujina, Senior Advocate, with Maithili Parikh, Omar Ahmad, Vikram Shah, Suraj Iyer and Gauri Joshi, i/b Ganesh and Co. For the Respondent(s): Mr. Kamalesh P Mali

Source: 2026 CaseBase(BOM) 250