Home

BSNL Must Pay Arrears As Calcutta HC Upholds Arbitral Award On Lease Termination

Copy LinkShareSave

The Calcutta High Court has fortified the finality of arbitral awards by refusing to interfere with a decision holding Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. (BSNL) liable for rent arrears due to a technically flawed lease termination notice. The ruling underscores that Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 does not permit a merits-based reassessment of an arbitrator’s plausible interpretation of contractual clauses.

A division bench comprising Justice Debangsu Basak and Justice Aryak Dutt dismissed the appeal filed by BSNL, which challenged a District Court's refusal to set aside an award passed by a former Chief Justice. The dispute centered on whether BSNL had effectively terminated a 25-year lease for a telephone exchange premises and whether supervening environmental restrictions constituted a frustration of the contract.

Key Takeaways

Finality of Arbitrator’s Interpretation

If an arbitrator adopts a plausible and possible view regarding the communication of a termination notice, the courts will not substitute it with their own reading under Section 34 or Section 37.

Pleading Waiver is Mandatory

Parties cannot raise the plea of 'waiver' of contractual rights for the first time during final arguments if it was not specifically pleaded in the initial statement of defense or counter-statement.

Strict Scope of Appellate Review

Appellate courts under Section 37 are prohibited from re-appreciating evidence or conducting an independent merit assessment, ensuring the 2015 Amendment’s goal of minimal judicial interference is met.

Environmental Bans Not Automatic Frustration

A regulatory order to shift operations does not automatically terminate a lease or prevent a tenant from formally surrendering possession as per the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

Court Observations and Directions

The Court noted that the arbitrator was the final judge of facts and pleadings. It observed that since the signed copy of the award was received within the condonable period, the challenge was maintainable but lacked merit. The Court emphasized that re-appreciation of evidence looked into by the Arbitrator is impermissible in a challenge under Section 34 and equally impermissible in an appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

The Court has following directions:

"F.M.A.T. No. 219 of 2021 is dismissed. The judgment and order dated 16th March, 2020, passed by the learned Additional District Judge, 5th Court at Barasat, North 24-Parganas, in Misc. Case No. 181 of 2016 is affirmed, and the arbitral award dated 13th May, 2016, is upheld. All other pending applications, if any, stand disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs."

The Court, in its reasoning, observed: "The learned Arbitrator held that a notice which must be given to the lessor operates only when it is communicated to him. On that view, the lessor received less than six months' notice. This view is a possible and plausible view. We will not substitute our view... The Transfer of Property Act, 1882, deals separately with a lessee's right to avoid the lease where the property is rendered substantially and permanently unfit for the purpose for which it was let out. No such case was made out by the appellant."

Ratio

An appellate court under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, cannot travel beyond the restrictions laid down under Section 34; specifically, it cannot undertake an independent assessment of the merits of the award or re-appreciate evidence if the arbitrator’s construction of the contract is plausible and does not shock the conscience of the court.

Background

The case involved a 25-year lease executed in 1997 for BSNL's telephone exchange. In 2006, the Pollution Control Board ordered the exchange to be shifted due to noise/pollution concerns. BSNL attempted to terminate the lease via a notice dated February 23, 2007, effective from August 2007. However, the lessor (represented by legal heirs) contested the termination, arguing that the six-month notice period required under Clause 7.1 only commenced upon actual receipt of the notice, which happened on March 14, 2007, resulting in a shortfall of days.

Following a reference by the High Court, the Sole Arbitrator ruled that the notice was ineffective and BSNL remained liable for rent. BSNL’s counter-claim for equipment damage was rejected for lack of personal knowledge by its witnesses. BSNL challenged this under Section 34, and subsequently under Section 37, citing Ssangyong Engineering & Construction Co. Ltd. v. National Highways Authority of India ( "(2019) 15 SCC 131": 2019 CaseBase(SC) 226) and Delhi Airport Metro Express (P) Ltd. v. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. ( "(2022) 1 SCC 131": 2021 CaseBase(SC) 1299) to argue patent illegality and perverse construction. The Respondents relied on Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. v. Sanman Rice Mills, Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC (JV) v. National Highways Authority of India, and Jan De Nul Dredging India (P) Ltd. v. Tuticorin Port Trust ( "(2026) 3 SCC 186": 2026 CaseBase(SC) 12) to emphasize judicial restraint. The High Court ultimately found that BSNL had retained the keys and possession, making the award for rent and repair costs legally sound under Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

Case Details:
Case No.: FMAT No. 219 of 2021
Neutral Citation: 2026:CHC-AS:1748-DB
Case Title: Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. Vs. Joysri Sengupta & Anr.
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. Kallol Basu, Adv.; Mr. Suman Banerjee, Adv.
For the Respondent(s): Mrs. Anupa Banerjee, Adv.; Mr. Rohan Shaw, Adv.

Source: 2026 CaseBase(CAL) 2936