Child Custody Matter | Supreme Court Orders Counselling To Prevent Sibling and Parental Alienation

Refusing to abruptly transfer a tutored child's custody back to the mother despite a clear breach of consent terms by the father, the Supreme Court has mandated court-monitored child counselling to counter severe parental and sibling alienation. A three-judge bench comprising Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta, and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh addressed a contempt petition arising out of a marital custody dispute. The mother alleged deliberate violation of a consent order governing child custody and visitation rights.
Key Takeaways
Child's Psychological Well-being Over Immediate Enforcement: The Supreme Court prioritized avoiding psychological trauma to a tutored child over the immediate enforcement of custody orders.
Mitigating Sibling Alienation: Judicial intervention was directed towards restoring faith in both the mother and the sibling to prevent long-term familial breakdown.
Structured Influence-Free Counselling: Trial courts were instructed to facilitate child counselling in neutral environments free from parental interference.
Court Observations and Directions
The Supreme Court noted that while the father was in clear contempt of the earlier court-approved settlement by unilaterally taking and retaining the minor child for four months, an abrupt restoration of physical custody could inflict permanent psychological scarring on the minor. The Bench observed that “Apparently, seen in the light of the facts noted above, the respondent-father is in clear contempt of this Court’s order dated 12th December, 2025 which, in terms of the settlement, placed full custody and guardianship rights of the children exclusively with the mother with limited visitation rights to the father. However, the child has been taken out of the custody of the mother and is retained by the father for nearly four months. There appears to be a conscious attempt by the father to brainwash and poison the mind of the child against his mother as well as sister. We, therefore, consider it unsafe to direct abrupt restoration of the child’s custody to the mother, as the same may create unnecessary complications and may also have a permanent scar on the child’s psychology.”
Ratio
When a minor child's mind is found to be severely tutored or brainwashed against a parent in breach of a court-approved custody arrangement, courts must prioritize the child's psychological stability through influence-free professional counselling and gradual reintegration rather than ordering an immediate physical handover that risks permanent emotional harm and sibling alienation.
Background
The dispute arose from a transfer petition involving a marital breakdown. During mediation, the mother and father entered into a mutual settlement on November 13, 2025, which was recorded by the Supreme Court on December 12, 2025. Under the agreement, custody of the two minor children, a daughter and a son, was granted exclusively to the mother, while the father received limited visitation rights to take the children to his parental home in Dholpur, Rajasthan twice a year for four days. On July 22, 2026, the father allegedly took the minor son from his school in Delhi under the guise of exercising visitation rights and unlawfully retained him in Dholpur. The mother filed a police complaint and served a legal notice, but the child was not returned. Consequently, the mother filed a contempt petition before the Supreme Court.
In response, the father defended his actions, claiming that the child shared a strong bond with him, resisted returning to the mother, and alleged physical and mental trauma at the mother's residence. Upon interacting with the child in Chambers, the Supreme Court observed that the child appeared severely tutored against his mother and sister. The Court also noted prima facie signs of substance abuse by the father.
While finding the father in clear contempt, the Supreme Court deferred the immediate return of custody and instead ordered structured counselling sessions at the Family Court, Dholpur, directing a progress report to be submitted in a sealed cover by January 22, 2027.
Case Details:
Case No.: Contempt Petition (C) No. 738 of 2026 in Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 235 of 2025
Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1249
Case Title: Poornima Gupta v. Saurav Gupta
Source: 2026 CaseBase(SC) 10309



