Excise Privilege Fees Valid on License Name Change Following Amalgamation: Bombay HC

The Bombay High Court has affirmed the State's authority to levy privilege fees for transferring excise licenses even when such transfers occur as a result of a court-sanctioned scheme of arrangement, clarifying that excise regulations operate independently of company law vesting.
In a proceeding presided over by Justice Amit Borkar, the Court addressed a challenge against the demand for five times the license fee for the transfer of 'PLL' and 'I' form licenses. The bench determined that the request for recording licenses in a new name triggered statutory exercises under excise law, making the petitioner liable for the prescribed fees regardless of the automatic vesting provisions in the Companies Act, 1956.
Legal Autonomy of Excise Regulations Over Amalgamation Schemes
The Court, in its reasoning, observed: "The Scheme of Arrangement derives its authority under the Companies Act. On the other hand, recovery of privilege fees is governed by the Maharashtra Prohibition Act and the Bombay Prohibition (Privileges Fees) Rules, 1954. Both these provisions operate in different fields and for different purposes... while the Scheme supports the petitioners on the question of vesting of licenses, it does not decide the issue regarding liability to pay privilege fees."
The Court further clarified that although the Section 391 and Section 394 of the Companies Act, 1956 facilitated the transfer of assets, it did not grant immunity from statutory dues under the Maharashtra Prohibition Act, 1949. It was noted that the petitioners initiated the transfer process by making an application in 2011, by which time the Bombay Prohibition (Privileges Fees) Rules, 1954 had been amended to increase the fees.
Court's Decision on Excessive Fee Demands
While upholding the primary privilege fees, the Court found a specific demand for the DS-I license (denatured spirit) to be unauthorized. The Court noted that the State could not provide a statutory basis for demanding Rs. 10,000 when the rules prescribed a lower fee.
The Court has the following directions:
"(i) The writ petition is partly allowed;
(ii) The order dated 23 August 2018 passed by the Minister of State Excise confirming the orders dated 6 May 2011 and 11 May 2011 is partly quashed and set aside only to the extent it confirms the demand of Rs.10,000/- towards transfer of the DS-I licence;
(iii) It is held that the respondents were justified in invoking Rule 5 of the Bombay Prohibition (Privileges Fees) Rules, 1954 while considering the petitioners' application dated 22 March 2011 for transfer of the licences in Forms 'PLL' and 'I'. The challenge to the levy of privilege fees in respect of those licences is rejected;
(iv) The demand of Rs.10,000/- towards transfer of the DS-I licence is declared to be unsustainable. The respondents shall recover only such transfer fee as was legally payable under the applicable statutory Rules governing the DS-I licence on the relevant date;
(v) If the petitioners have already paid any amount towards transfer of the DS-I licence in excess of the amount legally payable under the applicable Rules, the excess amount shall be refunded to the petitioners within a period of eight weeks from the date of uploading of this judgment."
Background:
The dispute originated from a Scheme of Arrangement where Chitali Distillery Limited, previously a State-owned entity, was merged with the petitioner company. Following a share purchase agreement in 2008 and subsequent court approvals, the petitioner applied to the Excise Department in March 2011 to mutate the licenses into their name.
The State authorities demanded Rs. 1,51,16,510 based on an amendment to the Bombay Prohibition (Privileges Fees) Rules, 1954 dated July 7, 2010, which mandated a fee of five times the license cost for transfers. The petitioners argued that since the share transfer occurred in 2008, the unamended rules (charging only a normal fee) should apply. However, the Court rejected this, stating the "event" for the fee was the 2011 application for name change, not the 2008 share transfer.
Case Details:
Case No.: WRIT PETITION NO.2391 OF 2019
Case Title: John Distilleries Private Lilmited Vs. The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. Suraj Kaushik with Ms. Megha Jani i/by Mr. Vinayak Salokhe
For the Respondent(s): Mr. A.I. Patel, Additional G.P. with Smt. S.S. Jadhav, AGP
Source: 2026 CaseBase(BOM) 260



