Home

Individual Liberty Trumps Moral Acceptability in Live-In Relationships: Punjab & Haryana HC

Copy LinkShareSave

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has reaffirmed that the constitutional protection of life and liberty is an absolute right that cannot be denied to couples in live-in relationships, even if one partner has not attained the legal marriageable age. Justice Divya Sharma adjudicated the matter, emphasizing that the court's primary duty in such writ petitions is the protection of individuals from imminent physical harm rather than a scrutiny of their marital status. The Bench was moved by a couple seeking protection of their life and liberty against interference from private respondents, despite the second petitioner being below the marriageable age of 21 years.

Key Takeaways

Primacy of Life and Liberty

Constitutional protection under Article 21 is a paramount consideration that overrides concerns regarding the legal validity or moral standing of a relationship.

Police Accountability Mandated

Law enforcement authorities are under a specific legal obligation to act expeditiously on threat representations, regardless of judicial observations on the relationship's social status.

Safety Over Status

Non-attainment of the legal marriageable age by a partner does not disqualify a couple from seeking state protection against physical threats or harassment.

Judicial Rationale on Personal Safety

The Punjab and Haryana High Court noted that the petitioners, despite being unmarried and one being underage for marriage, were living together out of their free will. The Bench highlighted that the issue of granting protection to live-in couples is no longer an open question, relying on the precedent set in Tamnna and another Vs. State of Punjab and others.

Addressing the evolution of this legal principle, the Punjab and Haryana High Court referenced a situation where a Coordinate Bench had previously dismissed a similar plea in Gulza Kumari and Gurwinder Singh v. State of Punjab on the grounds that such relationships were "morally and socially not acceptable." However, the Court pointed out that the Supreme Court of India, as seen in Gulza Kumari v. State of Punjab (Special Leave to Appeal (Criminal) No.4028 of 2021), had effectively overturned this logic by emphasizing that police must act uninfluenced by such moral observations when life and liberty are at stake.

Ratio

The right to protection of life and liberty is a paramount constitutional guarantee that must be enforced by the state machinery upon the assessment of a genuine threat perception, independent of the legal validity, social acceptability, or moral standing of the petitioners' relationship.

Background

The dispute reached the High Court when two petitioners, aged approximately 19 and 20 years respectively, sought directions against the official respondents to protect them from private respondents No. 4 to 8. Petitioner No. 2 had not yet attained the marriageable age of 21 years. The petitioners contended they were living in a "Live-in Relationship" out of free will and had submitted a representation to the Superintendent of Police, Ambala, which remained pending. The State did not object to the limited prayer for looking into the threat representation. The Punjab and Haryana High Court ultimately disposed of the petition by mandating a threat assessment while clarifying that the protection order does not grant immunity from any separate criminal proceedings if the petitioners are involved in any case.

Case Details:
Case No.: CRWP-13644-2026
Case Title: Garima and another Versus State of Haryana and others
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. Imran Mohd. Advocate
For the Respondent(s): Mr. Gaurav Bansal, DAG, Haryana.

Source: 2026 CaseBase(PNH) 30624