Typists Denied Pay Parity With Clerks in University Service: Patna HC

Steno-typists and typists cannot claim a statutory right to pay scale upgradation at par with the clerical cadre, as the two form distinct classes for whom separate policy decisions apply. The Patna High Court has clarified that the State's resolution for pay enhancement is limited to its intended beneficiaries, and extending such benefits to non-eligible cadres would violate the principles of reasonable classification.
A Single Judge Bench of Justice G. Anupama Chakravarthy adjudicated upon a writ petition seeking a mandamus for the grant of a higher pay scale (Rs. 5500-9000) and subsequent revisions for a petitioner who served at a College of Fisheries. The core dispute centered on whether a typist, after superannuation, could claim the same financial benefits as a Head Clerk based on existing State policy resolutions.
Key Takeaways
Cadre Distinction Upheld
Typists and Clerks are categorized as separate classes of employees, and policy benefits granted to one do not automatically accrue to the other.
Policy-Driven Pay Fixation
Upgradation of pay scales is strictly a policy decision of the State; courts cannot compel the extension of such benefits unless a statutory right is established.
Permissible Discrimination
Class discrimination between different service cadres is permissible under Article 14 of the Constitution, provided they form separate classes of persons.
Court Observations and Directions
The Court observed that the petitioner had superannuated from the post of Upper Division Clerk (Typist) and did not belong to the cadre of Clerks or Head Clerks. Following the precedent set in L.P.A. No. 766 of 2016, the Bench noted that the State's resolution specifically targeted Clerks and Head Clerks, excluding Steno-Typists from the ambit of the pay upgradation policy.
The Court has the following directions:
"(i) Issuance of appropriate writ in the nature of MANDAMUS, commanding/directing the Respondents to grant the pay scale of Rs. 5500-9000 with effect from 1.1.1996 and revised pay scale of Rs-9300 to 34,800 Grade Pay Rs- 4600 to the petitioner...
(ii) Issuance of appropriate writ in the nature of mandamus, commanding/ directing the Respondents to grant the pay scale equivocation to pay scale of Assistant..."
Note: While the petitioner prayed for the above, the Court ultimately found no merit. The Court, in its reasoning, observed: "...the petitioner superannuated from the post of UDC (Typist), and does not belong to the cadre of Clerks or Head Clerks. The benefit of upgradation of pay scale under the policy decision of the State has been extended only to Clerks and Head Clerks, and no such benefit has been extended to Typists/Steno-Typists. Therefore, the petitioner has no statutory right to claim upgradation of pay scale at par with Clerks and Head Clerks."
Ratio
Fixation and upgradation of pay scales are sovereign policy decisions of the State. Employees belonging to a distinct cadre (such as Typists) do not possess a statutory right to claim parity with another cadre (such as Clerks) if the State resolution specifically limits the benefits to the latter. Such classification is legally valid and protected under the constitutional framework of equality.
Background
The petitioner, Tej Narayan Lal Karna, originally sought a mandamus to command the University and State respondents to grant him a revised pay scale effective from 1996, asserting that his work was similar to that of an Assistant at the University Headquarters. He relied on the Division Bench judgment in L.P.A. No. 766 of 2016, arguing he was entitled to the upgradation benefits intended for Head Clerks.
However, the State and University respondents countered by producing records showing the petitioner retired as a UDC (Typist) from the Sanjay Gandhi Institute of Dairy Technology. They argued that because the State resolution for pay upgradation explicitly mentioned only Clerks and Head Clerks, a Typist could not bridge the cadre gap to claim the same. The Court relied on established precedents including The Union of India and Ors. Vs. Rajib Khan and Ors., P.U. Joshi and Ors. Vs. Accountant General, Ahemdabad, Union of India and Ors. Vs. Pushpa Rani and ors., and S.C. Chandra and Ors. Vs. State of Jharkhand and Ors. ( "(2007) 8 SCC 279": 2007 CaseBase(SC) 315) to emphasize that pay fixation is a complex policy matter. Consequently, the High Court dismissed the writ petition, finding no statutory or constitutional violation in the denial of the higher pay scale to the petitioner.
Case Details:
Case No.: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.6168 of 2016
Case Title: Tej Narayan Lal Karna v. The State of Bihar & Others
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. Gajanan Arun, Advocate
For the State: Mr. Ram Sumiran Rai, GA-23; Mr. Bipin Kumar, AC to GA-23
For the University: Mr. VijayhShankar Upadhyay, Advocate
For the Res. No. 8 to 10: Mr. Sriram Krishna, Advocate
For the Res. No. 11: Mr. Kunal Tiwary, Advocate
Source: 2026 CaseBase(PAT) 3973