Home

Pay Parity Cannot Be Denied Due to Entry Route: Gujarat HC

Copy LinkShareSave

In a significant ruling for public service parity, the Gujarat High Court has established that once employees are regularized into the same cadre, their initial mode of entry, whether as a daily-wager or work-charge employee, cannot justify pay discrepancies favoring a junior.

A bench of Justice N.S. Sanjay Gowda and Justice J. L. Odedra overturned a previous Single Judge decision, emphasizing that seniority in a cadre must be reflected in the pay scale. The Court addressed a petition by an employee who sought pay parity with a junior colleague after a long-standing legal battle for regularization.

Legal Principle: Uniformity Within the Same Cadre

The Court observed that the fundamental purpose of a cadre is to ensure uniformity among its members. While length of service might lead to variations in total salary, the basic pay scale for the same cadre must remain consistent. The Court noted that the petitioner was regularized as a Clerk-cum-Typist effective from 1997, whereas her colleague, though starting as a work-charge employee, was regularized only in 2000.

Court's Rationale on Entry Modes and Pay Protection

The respondent Board had argued that the junior colleague's pay was protected under a specific Government Resolution because he originated from a work-charge establishment. However, the Court rejected this, stating that such protection cannot result in a senior regularized employee drawing a lower salary.

The Court, in its reasoning, observed: "It cannot be in dispute that, in law, normally, persons in the same cadre would be entitled to the same pay scale. The very purpose of having persons in the same cadre is to ensure that they all have the same pay scale. It is no doubt true that persons in the same cadre may be drawing higher salaries because of their length of service, but their basic pay scale in the cadre would necessarily be the same."

Regarding the Board's reliance on precedents like State of Uttaranchal and Anr. v. Shiv Charan Singh Bhandari & Ors. ( "(2013) 12 SCC 179": 2013 CaseBase(SC) 937), Maheshkumar Chandulal Patel & Anr. v. State of Gujarat & Ors., and Amreli District Panchayat v. District Development Officer, Amreli & Anr., the Court distinguished these cases, noting that they involved different factual scenarios such as direct appointees versus senior ad-hoc lecturers.

Directions Issued to the Gujarat Maritime Board

The Court has the following directions:

"The Board is directed to grant the petitioner the same pay scale that had been paid to Mukesh N. Langalia w.e.f. 11.03.1997. All consequential benefits shall also be granted to the petitioner. The entire exercise of computing the benefits and making over the arrears shall be undertaken and completed within a period of three months from the date of receipt of this order."

Background:

The appellant joined the Gujarat Maritime Board in 1984 as a daily wage Clerk. After decades of litigation, including a 2001 High Court order and a 2014 contempt proceeding, her services were finally regularized effective from March 11, 1997. Despite being senior to one Mukesh Langalia (regularized in 2000), she found that Langalia was receiving a higher basic pay due to his previous status as a work-charge employee.

The petitioner approached the Court in 2022 seeking pay stepping-up. The Single Judge had originally dismissed the petition on the grounds of delay and laches, noting the grievance dated back to 1999. However, the Division Bench clarified that the petitioner only secured her regularization rights in 2014 and could not have known the specific pay details of her colleague earlier. Under 2002 Rules, the claim for parity was deemed legitimate. The Court set aside the Single Judge's order and allowed the appeal.

Case Details:
Case No.: R/LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO. 323 of 2026
NeutralCitation: 2026:GUJHC:36430-DB
Case Title: ASHOK IJJATRAY ANJARIA v. GUJARAT MARITIME BOARD & ANR.
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): MS HARSHAL N PANDYA
For the Respondent(s): MS SEJAL K MANDAVIA

Source: 2026 CaseBase(GUJ) 289