Electricity Distribution Infrastructure Charges Liable to VAT as Deemed Sale: Telangana HC

The Telangana High Court has delivered a significant blow to power distribution companies, ruling that service line and development charges recovered from consumers for infrastructure projects constitute a 'transfer of right to use goods' exigible to tax. The Court held that even while maintaining control and ownership, recovering the full cost of equipment like transformers and cables for exclusive consumer use satisfies the criteria for a deemed sale under state tax laws.
In this matter, a bench comprising Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda heard a challenge against a tax assessment seeking to levy Value Added Tax on the amounts collected for electricity supply infrastructure under the Andhra Pradesh Value Added Tax Act, 2005.
Key Takeaways
Statutory Recovery as Taxable Turnover
Infrastructure costs recovered under Section 46 of the Electricity Act, 2003 are not immune from taxation if they satisfy the ingredients of a deemed sale under VAT laws.
De facto Transfer of Use
Exclusive use of service lines by a specific applicant, funded entirely by that applicant, constitutes a transfer of the right to use, even if the utility provider retains maintenance responsibility.
Broadening 'Business' Scope
Activities ancillary or subsidiary to a principal tax-exempt activity (like electricity supply) are liable to tax if the ancillary transaction itself falls within a charging provision.
Impact of Ownership and Control on Taxability
The petitioner argued that because they retained ownership, maintenance, and control of the infrastructure under the Electricity Act, 2003 and the General Terms and Conditions of Supply, no transfer of the right to use could occur. However, the Telangana High Court observed that the recovery of the entire cost from specified applicants, such as real estate developers, created a taxable event. The Court relied on principles established in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others ( "(2006) 145 STC 91": 2006 CaseBase(SC) 1086) to determine that the substance of the contract and the intention of the parties regarding the use of goods were paramount.
In its reasoning, the Telangana High Court observed that “The recovery of the entire cost of the goods utilized in developing the infrastructure constitutes an ancillary or subsidiary activity connected with the petitioners principal business of supplying electricity. There is a clear element of recovery of the value of the goods employed in developing the infrastructure on the land belonging to the consumer, for the purpose of facilitating the supply of electricity.” The Bench further clarified that while the consumers do not own the equipment, their exclusive entitlement to receive electricity through those specific lines establishes a transfer of the right to use those goods. This was supported by the interpretation of Constitution of India, 1950 and precedents like Viceroy Hotels Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer and Great Eastern Shipping Co. Ltd. v. State of Karnataka ( "(2020) 3 SCC 354": 2019 CaseBase(SC) 2392).
The Telangana High Court clarified that "...the transaction in question constitutes a transfer of the right to use the goods and consequently, attracts the levy of tax. Accordingly, the tax levied on the value of the goods recovered by the petitioners is exigible at the applicable rates under Section 4(8) of the Andhra Pradesh Value Added Tax Act, 2005. Consequently, the question framed for consideration is answered in favour of respondent and the petitioners are not entitled to the relief sought in the writ petition. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed."
Ratio
A transaction constitutes a 'transfer of the right to use goods' under Article 366(29-A)(d) of the Constitution of India, 1950 and state VAT laws when the full cost of identifiable goods is recovered from a consumer for infrastructure developed for their exclusive use, regardless of the provider retaining maintenance control or the lack of an express lease agreement.
Background
The dispute began when the Commercial Tax Department audited the Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Ltd (formerly APCPDCL) and discovered that while electricity supply was exempt, the company was recovering the full value of goods (poles, transformers, cables) from real estate developers and specific applicants under 'service line charges' and 'development charges'. The department issued a show-cause notice proposing to levy 12.5% tax under Section 4(8) of the Andhra Pradesh Value Added Tax Act, 2005 on a turnover of approximately Rs. 241 Crores.
The petitioner contended that the infrastructure became immovable property upon being embedded in the earth and that consumers had no 'effective control' as per State of Andhra Pradesh and Another vs. Rashtriya Ispat Nagar Limited. The respondents countered that the goods were identified at the time of sanction and their exclusive use by the consumer for power reception met the legal threshold for a deemed sale. The Telangana High Court ultimately sided with the revenue department, dismissing the writ petition and upholding the tax demand.
Case Details:
Case No.: WRIT PETITION No.3356 of 2009
Case Title: M/s. Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Ltd. v. The State of Andhra Pradesh and others
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. S. Suri Babu, Advocate for Mr. S. Krishna Murthy
For the Respondent(s): Mr. Swaroop Oorilla, Special Government Pleader for State Tax
Source: 2026 CaseBase(TEL) 34932



