Home

Karnataka High Court Upholds Validity of Combined Experience Certificates For MVI Recruitment

Copy LinkShareSave

In a decisive check on bureaucratic rigidity, the Karnataka High Court has ruled that a 'supervening impossibility' in meeting statutory work experience standards cannot be a ground to disqualify candidates, specifically striking down the rejection of aspirants who failed to prove experience in non-existent petrol-engine heavy vehicles.

A division bench comprising Justice R Devdas and Justice Dr. K. Manmadha Rao delivered this significant verdict while adjudicating a batch of writ petitions concerning the recruitment of 150 Motor Vehicle Inspectors (MVI). The dispute primarily centered on the interpretation of work experience requirements stipulated under the recruitment notification issued by the Transport Department.

Key Takeaways

Aggregate Experience Validated

Providing that combined experience across multiple workshops is sufficient to meet the one-year threshold if the individual workshops individually lack the full duration.

Doctrine of Impossibility Applied

Recognizing that candidates cannot be penalized for failing to meet standards such as experience with petrol-engine heavy vehicles that are technically or practically impossible to satisfy in the current industry.

Relief for Bonafide Candidates

Directing the state to stop the 'travesty of justice' where honest certificates were rejected while technically false certificates from state corporations were blindly accepted.

Interpretation of Experience under C&R Rules

The core controversy involved the interpretation of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and the Cadre and Recruitment Rules, 2013. The State contended that a candidate must possess exactly one year of experience in each category of vehicle Light Motor Vehicles (LMV), Heavy Goods Vehicles (HGV), and Heavy Passenger Vehicles (HPV). Conversely, candidates argued that an aggregate of one year across these categories should suffice. The Court found the rules to be ambiguous.

In its reasoning, the Court observed: "A plain reading of the provision makes it clear that there is ambiguity in prescribing the requisite experience. There can be different interpretations of the provision and surely the provision cannot be read to mean that a candidate must possess work experience of at least one year in all the three types of vehicles – LMV, HGV and HPV, fitted with petrol and diesel engine."

The Anomaly of Petrol-Engine Heavy Vehicles

The Court took sharp exception to the department's insistence on experience with petrol-engine HGVs and HPVs, noting that such vehicles have not existed in India for decades. Relying on In Re Presidential Poll, the Court invoked the legal maxims impotentia excusat legam and lex non cogit ad impossibilia, asserting that the law does not compel the performance of the impossible.

The Court has issued the following directions:

"i) W.P.No.126/2025 filed by the State of Karnataka, Commissioner, Transport Department, is dismissed.

ii) W.P.No.5483/2025, W.P.No.5701/2025, W.P.No.16415/2025, W.P.No.27642/2025, W.P.No.4958/2026 and W.P.No.21767/2026 are allowed. These are cases where the candidatures are rejected on the ground of not having experience in HGVs and HPVs with petrol engines. The impugned orders passed by the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal in Applications No.2863/2024, 1466/2024, 1773/2024, 1783/2024, 3132/2024 and 1785/2024 are hereby quashed and set aside.

iii) If the names of such candidates are found in the Revised Final Select List dated 26.10.2023, then the Commissioner, Transport Department, shall issue appointment orders to such candidates. Such candidates shall be entitled for all benefits, including seniority on par with the candidates who were appointed pursuant to the Revised Final Select List dated 26.10.2023, in accordance with law.

iv) W.P.No.25888/2025 is allowed. The impugned orders passed by the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal in Application No.3837/2024 is hereby quashed and set aside. Since the candidate has more than a year’s experience in all the three types of vehicles, even according to the report of the Deputy Commissioner and since his name is found in the Revised Final Select List dated 26.10.2023, the Commissioner, Transport Department shall proceed to issue appointment order to the candidate.

v) The appointment orders shall be issued as expeditiously as possible and at any rate within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order."

Ratio

Where a recruitment rule regarding work experience is ambiguous or prescribes a standard that is impossible to perform due to external industrial realities (such as the non-existence of specific vehicle types), the benefit must be extended to the candidate. Combined or aggregate experience from multiple workshops/garages satisfies the requirement of 'at least one year' if the total duration meets the threshold and covers the required vehicle classes.

Background

The recruitment process for 150 MVIs began in 2016. It was previously litigated in Sri Lokesh V.R. And Others Vs. The State Of Karnataka And Others regarding whether an amendment to Section 213(4) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (which deleted the experience requirement) applied retrospectively. The Court had ruled it was not retrospective but directed Karnataka Public Service Commission (KPSC) to verify certificates. Subsequently, many candidates were denied appointments because their experience was either 'aggregated' from different workshops or lacked mention of petrol engines for heavy vehicles. The Court referred to Parvaiz Ahmad Parry Vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir and Others ( "(2015) 17 SCC 709": 2015 CaseBase(SC) 452) to emphasize that the best candidates should not be excluded based on vague qualification descriptions. Ultimately, the Court found the State's rejection of 'truthful' certificates while accepting 'false' ones from State Corporations (claiming petrol-engine heavy vehicle experience) to be a travesty of justice.

Case Details:
Case No.: WP No. 126 of 2025 C/W WP No. 5483 of 2025 and others
Neutral Citation: 2026:KHC:55400-DB
Case Title: The State Of Karnataka Vs. Sri Srinivasa B N And Others
Appearances:
For the Petitioner(s): Sri. Reuben Jacob, Aag A/W Sri. K.R.Rajendra, Aga; Sri. Nitin Ramesh, Advocate; Sri. Prithveesh M K, Advocate; Sri. Udaya Holla, Sr. Counsel
For the Respondent(s): Sri. Nitin Ramesh, Advocate; Sri. A.N. Guna Ranjan, Advocate; Smt. Sinchana M.R., Advocate; Sri. Mohammed Shamil, Advocate; Sri. N.C.Srinivasa, Advocate

Source: 2026 CaseBase(KAR) 26203