Home

Special off‑road construction equipment used inside plants are not motor vehicles for road‑tax purposes, Supreme Court rules

Copy LinkShareSave

A Bench of Justices Pankaj Mithal and Prasanna B. Varale heard appeals by Ultratech Cement Ltd. and others challenging Gujarat government demands to register and levy road tax on heavy earth‑moving machinery and construction equipment such as dumpers, loaders, excavators, dozers and surface miners. The question before the Court was whether such machines qualified as “motor vehicles” under Section 2(28) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and were liable to tax under the Gujarat Motor Vehicles Tax Act, 1958.

The Court allowed the appeals and set aside the impugned High Court judgments that had held the machines taxable. It held that vehicles of the special type used only within factories or other enclosed premises — described in the rules as “construction equipment vehicles” — fell within the exclusion in the statutory definition of “motor vehicle” and therefore could not be taxed under Entry 57, List II of the Seventh Schedule or the Gujarat Tax Act, save when they actually used public roads. The Court emphasised the constitutional and statutory limits on State taxation powers and noted that Schedule I to the Gujarat Tax Act did not prescribe tax rates for construction equipment vehicles. The Court clarified that “if any such kind of vehicles are found using roads, they would not be free from the rigors of Section 2(28) of the Act and Section 3 of the Gujarat Tax Act and may also be subject to proceedings for seizure and penalty in accordance with the law.”

The Court, in its reasoning, observed: “On a composite reading of Section 3 of the Gujarat Tax Act, the definition of motor vehicles under Section 2 (28) of the Act, the definition of construction equipment vehicles contained in Rule 2 (cab) of the Rules and Schedule I of the Gujarat Tax Act, it is crystal clear that the vehicles of the kind used by the appellant which are special vehicles i.e., construction equipment vehicles may be suitable for plying upon roads are essentially meant to be used in a factory or an enclosed premises and as such are not chargeable to tax under the Gujarat Tax Act. Even otherwise in view of the language employed in Entry 57 of List II of Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India, no authority is authorized to levy or collect tax on vehicles which are not suitable for use on roads and have been designed for off-road use in factory or enclosed premises.”

Background The appellants operated cement plants in Gujarat and used heavy earth‑moving machinery and special‑service vehicles within plant premises. The Regional Transport Officer had initially acknowledged in 1996 that dumpers used within private premises did not require registration, but the Transport Commissioner later directed registration and taxation by public advertisement in 1999 and follow‑up inspections. Show‑cause notices issued in 2006 demanded arrears, interest and penalty; the appellant deposited sums under protest and challenged the demands before the Gujarat High Court, which dismissed the petitions in July 2011. The appellants relied on manufacturers’ certificates and expert reports (including from Automotive Research Association of India) showing the machines were designed for off‑road, factory or mining use and were transported to sites on trailers in knocked‑down condition. They further relied on this Court’s precedent in Bolani Ores Ltd. and later authority in Tarachand Logistic Solutions Ltd. The State relied on the charging language of Section 3(1) of the Gujarat Tax Act and earlier decisions holding similar machinery taxable.

The Supreme Court examined Article 265 and Entry 57, List II of the Seventh Schedule, Section 3 of the Gujarat Tax Act, Section 2(28) of the Motor Vehicles Act and Rule 2(cab) of the Central Rules, and treated the exclusion for vehicles “adapted for use only in a factory or in any other enclosed premises” as determinative. The Court distinguished authorities which did not consider the express exclusion in Section 2(28) and read Bolani Ores Ltd. as supportive. It also observed that the Ministry of Road Transport & Highways’ circular (13.07.2020) classifying such machines as off‑road equipment did not override statute but was relevant to departmental practice. The Supreme Court set aside the High Court orders, allowed the appeals and directed that the machinery, while excluded when confined to off‑road factory use, would remain liable if actually used on public roads; it made no order as to costs.

Case Details: Case No.: 2026 INSC 43; Civil Appeal Nos. 3352-3353 of 2017; also Civil Appeal Nos. 3357 & 3358 of 2017 Case Title: Ultratech Cement Ltd. v. The State of Gujarat & Ors. Appearances: For the Petitioner(s): Shri P. Chidambaram, Senior Counsel; Shri Nakul Dewan, Senior Counsel For the Respondent(s): Shri K. Parameshwar, Senior Counsel