Home

High Court Upholds RTAs' Power To Require AIS‑052 Bus‑Body And BS‑VI Compliance For New Stage Carriage Permits

Copy LinkShareSave

A bench of Justice Mohammed Nias C.P. heard a batch of writ petitions by applicants who challenged decisions of the State Transport Authority (STA) and various Regional Transport Authorities (RTAs) that granted or rejected regular stage carriage permits subject to compliance with AIS‑052 bus‑body design standards and BS‑VI emission norms. The petitions raised the common question whether insistence on those standards at the permit stage amounted to an indirect and unlawful fixation of vehicle age contrary to Rule 260A of the Kerala Motor Vehicles Rules and binding precedent.

The High Court held that RTAs lawfully exercised powers under Section 72(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 to impose conditions as to the “specified description” of vehicles authorised by a permit and that statutory standards embodied in the Central Motor Vehicles Rules (notably Rule 125‑C incorporating AIS‑052 and Rule 115 on emissions) could be insisted upon while granting permits. The court rejected the petitioners’ contention that the requirement operated as an impermissible age limit and declined to treat compliance with AIS‑052 and BS‑VI as a disguised fixation of vehicle age. The Court, in its reasoning, observed: "Section 72(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act of 1988 gives the RTA the authority to impose conditions when granting a stage carriage permit. The authority is expressly authorised by clauses (X) and (XI) to mandate that vehicles utilised under the permit be of a particular type, equipped with bodies that meet approved specifications, and adhere to specified standards of cleanliness, comfort, and safety. The phrase "specified description" in Section 72(2) has a broad meaning and cannot be interpreted to exclude the CMV Rules regarding construction and safety requirements." The court further noted that one object of the Act was the "encouragement of adoption of higher technology in the automotive sector" and emphasised the statutory focus on passenger safety and environmental protection.

Background The batch comprised over twenty writ petitions (led by W.P.(C) No.36460/2025 and connected cases) in which petitioners challenged RTA/STA actions taken in mid‑2025 that either granted regular stage‑carriage permits subject to mandatory AIS‑052 and BS‑VI compliance or rejected/withheld permits for want of production of AIS‑052/BS‑VI‑compliant vehicles. Petitioners relied on this Court’s earlier decision in Shahabudheen and Others v. State Transport Authority (2020) and Rule 260A of the Kerala Motor Vehicles Rules to say that the field of permissible vehicle age was occupied by statute and that administrative insistence on specifications at the permit stage amounted to an illegitimate indirect age restriction. They contended that many impugned conditions were imposed before the STA formally resolved its policy on 08.08.2025 and therefore lacked authority.

Respondents, represented by the State Transport Authority and RTAs, countered that Section 72(2) authorised the imposition of conditions as to the "specified description" of vehicles and that Rules 125‑C and 115 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules statutorily incorporated AIS‑052 bus‑body standards and emission norms. They urged harmonious construction of Chapters IV (registration, construction and equipment) and V (permits) of the Motor Vehicles Act and relied upon earlier High Court and Supreme Court authorities recognising the regulatory duty to protect passenger safety and prevent permit trafficking.

After hearing, the court held that compliance with AIS‑052 and BS‑VI addressed construction, safety and environmental standards which RTAs could lawfully require in granting permits and that incidental exclusion of older vehicles did not equate to an unlawful age fixation. The court observed that a fitness certificate under Section 56 did not confer an absolute right to a permit for a particular service. To secure uniform application, the court directed the STA to issue appropriate directions to all RTAs. The court quashed impugned orders insofar as they insisted on AIS‑052/BS‑VI compliance in relation to permits granted prior to 01.09.2025 and directed reconsideration, where relevant, in light of the law as it stood before that date. The court also recorded an earlier interim clarification dated 20.11.2025 and disposed of the writ petitions accordingly.

Case Details: Case No.: W.P.(C) Nos. 36460, 20638, 21253, 24048, 24059, 33089, 35967, 35983, 36019, 36491, 37193, 39009, 39598, 43308, 43370, 43600, 44593, 44753, 45194, 45491, 45495, 46004, 46037, 46057, 48223 of 2025 and W.P.(C) No. 298 of 2026 Case Title: Writ petitions challenging decisions of the State Transport Authority / Regional Transport Authorities relating to grant, rejection or conditional grant of regular stage carriage permits (batch disposal) Appearances: For the Petitioner(s): Shri K.V. Gopinathan Nair; Shri O.D. Sivadas; Shri M. Jithesh Menon; Shri Saju J. Vallyara; Shri K.H. Asif (counsel for various petitioners as per connected matters) For the Respondent(s): Smt. Surya Binoy, Senior Government Pleader (for the State Transport Authority and Regional Transport Authorities)